What Not to Do When Hosting a Whisky Tasting

Hosting a whisky tasting for the first time can feel like a lot of responsibility. Will people enjoy it? Have I chosen the right whiskies? Do I know enough?

The good news is that creating a memorable tasting has less to do with being an expert and more to do with making your guests feel comfortable.

We asked some of our teachers and contributing experts about the most common mistakes they see first-time tasting hosts make. Reassuringly, they're all super easy to avoid.

Watch the Video

Don't tell people what they should be tasting

One of the biggest temptations for a new host is to reveal the tasting notes before anyone has had a chance to explore the whisky themselves. Joe Cabassa believes that's one of the quickest ways to shut down conversation.

"The one thing you should never do is tell people what they should be nosing on that whisky. If somebody tells you it smells like honey, even if you don't see it, try to evolve on that... never say, 'No, you cannot find that note there.' Otherwise people close up and they don't participate in the tasting anymore."

The best tastings encourage curiosity, not correctness.

If one guest finds green apples, another honey and another freshly baked gingerbread from their great auntie's kitchen in Devon, it's fine! That's part of what makes tasting whisky so fascinating.

Rather than correcting people, ask questions.

"What makes you think of honey?"

"Does anyone else get something similar?"

These type of prompts often start the conversations that become more memorable than simply reading the tasting notes from the bottle.

Don't forget the food

Gordon Steele's take is brutal:

"Not providing enough food!"

A few well-chosen nibbles can make a big difference. Not only does a bit of food help guests pace themselves, it also creates natural breaks between whiskies and keeps the atmosphere relaxed and sociable.

You don't need a gourmet spread. Easy snacks like bread, cheese or charcuterie can be all that's needed to complement the tasting and keep everyone comfortable.

Don't overcomplicate the whisky

Tamdhu Distillery Manager Sandy MacIntyre sees another common trap.

"Probably trying to be over descriptive of the whiskies. Let people explore their own flavours and descriptors. Don't be too descriptive to them and ask them their opinions as well."

It's easy to assume a good host needs to impress people with an encyclopaedic vocabulary. In reality, guests usually enjoy themselves more when they're invited into the conversation. So, instead of listing dozens of flavour descriptors, ask simple questions.

What stands out? Is it sweet or dry? Light or rich? What does it remind you of?

There's no pressure for anyone to agree and that's exactly the point.

Keep it simple and sociable

Looking across all of our experts' advice, one message shines through. The biggest mistakes aren't about choosing the "wrong" whisky or forgetting obscure facts. They're about making people feel like they're being tested. A great tasting should feel like a conversation, not an exam.

Give your guests the confidence to explore, make sure everyone is well looked after, and remember that sharing different opinions is one of the best parts of discovering whisky together. After all, the goal isn't to find the "right" tasting note. It's to enjoy a great dram in great company.